Athletic Bilbao and ‘Cantera’

[COYS]

I was going to post this in the La Liga discussion. but I thought only a few people may see it, and it's quite an interesting article.

Athletic Bilbao and ‘Cantera’

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/9/9f/Athletic_c_de_bilbao.png/175px-Athletic_c_de_bilbao.png

Chances are that if you’re in the pub with your friends and the inevitable topic of football is discussed, and perhaps less inevitably Spanish football is mentioned (unless it’s a dig at Real Madrid), then Athletic Club Bilbao will not be high on the list of subjects.

But perhaps it should be. Amongst the arguments of ‘who’s better Messi or Ronaldo’, ‘who will David Villa join’, and, ‘oh by the way who’s round is it’, Athletic Club barely get a look in. However in today’s ever declining lack of footballing morals, ethics and loyalty, Athletic Bilbao at least deserve a drunken supportive rant.

Formed by British migrant workers in 1898, Bilbao has become somewhat of a romanticised club. They are team whom are idealised in a modern world where cheap footballing imports and the EU have almost brought the great youth systems of Europe it their knees.

Gone are the days of the Lisbon Lions who won the 1967 European Cup with players who were all born within 30 miles of Glasgow. Look at every Premier League team in England, only an average of 3 English players per team start every weekend. And yet, in a small part of Northern Spain a team has consistently defied the globalization of football and strove to preserve its values and fundamental beliefs in an age where football is slowly falling into an abyss filled with greed, monetization and self-interest.

The sun quietly descends behind the Stadio San Mamés, or ‘The Cathedral’ if you’re a Los Leones, as it is still sometime before the hustle and bustle of the new La Liga season comes to these shores. When you think of all the great names that have graced this pitch: the prolific Telmo Zarra, José Ángel Iribar and Joseba Etxeberria to name just a few you begin to see the curiosity and interés that surrounds this club. They are all Basque. They all hail from the Basque region of Northern Spain. And what makes the club more intriguing is that since 1912, almost 100 years ago, the Athletic Bilbao team has only consisted on Basque players. Remarkable. Do you think you would ever see Arsene Wenger or Alex Ferguson only playing footballers born in London or Manchester?

This policy of Cantera (literally ‘quarry’) is one that the club, the supporters and the Basque people are immensely proud of. By implementing this policy the club is ensuring the survival and promotion of the Basque game, they choose to nature their own talent rather than buy an import. It is also more than this. It is a stand against centralization. A voice that yells “we are Basque!”. During the 28 year reign of General Franco the Basque people suffered terrible oppression; their unique language, culture, customs, style were all banned, persecuted and oppressed because they didn’t fit in with the ideal of a one-nation Spain. It was conform or suffer the consequences. Support for Bilbao was a vote against Franco. Much in the same way that Barcelona is self-described as ‘more than a club’, Athletic Bilbao are similar, but they take it a step further.

And yet, not everyone looks upon Athletic Bilbao as the ideal football club.. Admittedly these critics mainly come from outside the region but perhaps they do have a point when they say that Cantera is restrictive to Bilbao’s progress. While it has cemented its position in footballing history as a club that is genuinely local (if you overlook the fact that it was created by foreigners), it has also been somewhat left behind when it comes to success.

They haven’t won a domestic trophy since 1984 and since we have entered the 21st century their highest finish has been 5th. Not bad you might say considering they are up against the likes of Real, Barcelona and Valencia who can open their cheque books and sign anyone from any part of the world, but when you consider their success historically in that they have won 8 La Liga titles and silalala behind Real Madrid and Barcelona in terms of league titles won; the policy of Cantera looks outdated and obsolete. A throwback to a distant age when football was idyllic and naïve.

And yet this isn’t the view of the club nor the fans. Their president, Fernando Garcia Macua, announced that “we’d rather go down than change our habits, I know the supporters feel the same.” They have only a 3 million strong population in which to find their next Telmo Zarra.

If the Arsenal Board decided that the club could only buy players that are part of, or have descended from, the 7.5m people that live in London there would be a revolt. But yet we look upon Bilbao as well, somehow right and honorable. Of course clubs should have a ‘local’ presence, of course they should protect and nurture their own; it’s a sorry state of affairs that most clubs have neither the will nor the courage to do so.

So next time you’ve have one too many Carlsbergs in the local and have moved on to why Messi is a hundred times better than Ronaldo, spare a thought for Bilbao. Because unless the Basque country has a sudden baby boom of superstars, Cantera might not be around for another 100 years.

[dena]

Best part is that more than 75% of the fans voted that they would rather be relegated than break the cantera tradition, the fact that they have never been relegated from La Liga and have 24 Copa del Rey's is very impressive. They've always been able to produce quality as well, dispute the Basque region being small, as seen by Llorente, Iraola and Javi M who have all garnered interest from big clubs.

[Ciudad-B]

I have great respect for Bilbao and this tradition. They are awesome for never being relegated even tho they only use basque players.

[SirReal Madrid]

I have total respect for Bilbao. Even if they despise us. I don't care. They walk the talk. When one says proud of being Basque, it's reflected by the players they have on their squad (unlike some other team). I t'd be nice to have other clubs like this but would probably make more sense in a smaller city as the big cities are very cosmopolitan and having a melting pot of players only reflects the city.

[barajma92]

Originally Posted by Ciudad-B

I have great respect for Bilbao and this tradition. They are awesome for never being relegated even tho they only use basque players.

Agreed. Respect for Bilbao

[Gorayfle]

Great article. Bilbao is amazing.

[Dan]

Takes a lot for a club to keep their traditions throughout every circumstance.. They still bring quality players through their ranks too..

Credit to them, it's also always a challenge on FM..

[DeacsWF]

That's impressive

[SubaruAdrian]

Surprised they haven't been branded "racist" by FIFA and forced to change or be fined out of existence.. Hopefully Sepp won't read the article.

[Strange Pirate]

I have always found Athletic club and trhe Basque region very interesting. Lot of respect for them.

[LilPancho86]

here's something interesting... Javier Iturriaga is a player of Basque ancestry who was born and grew up in Mexico City... he then went to Spain and played for Athletic Bilbao... and back when Hugo Sanchez was in charge of the Mexico NT, he was supposedly monitoring Iturriaga's progress... but with his sacking, a potential callup went down with it... now, 'Itu' somehow fell off the radar to a 3rd division Spanish team...

[forestfcfan]

Originally Posted by Danthomas2005

Takes a lot for a club to keep their traditions throughout every circumstance.. They still bring quality players through their ranks too..

Credit to them, it's also always a challenge on FM..

Haha i know

[Weather130]

Any team that has never been relegated is quite a story and with a tradition like this it is even more amazing.

[dena]

It's quite ironic how Bilbao's biggest rival Real Socidedad also held firm to the cantera but broke their tradition in the 90s, they shot up the leauge, finished second in La Liga (losing on the last day), and made the champions leauge, all depending on great foreign signings. Where are they now? La Segunda.