Macheda!

[Super-manc]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

I just cant see the "he doesnt look real so i cant use him" attitude. seems pretty childish to me.

As people have pointed out, when the game was produced he was a nobody (and still is in my eyes) therefor he got a generic look. Then he scores one good goal and getlalalala by someone elses shot and everyone is toasting him and to top it all off getting worried because he doesnt look real in fifa 09.

Answer me this. If he hadnt played against Villa and Sunderland would we still be having this discussion? Would you still be worried about how he looks?

Well sorry if I like to use the WHOLE SQUAD of the team I support instead of just the first choice xi.

I just think it's a lalalalalaeap creating a random player and sticking his name on the back of the shirt. The annoying thing is that it's volunteers who edit and give feedback on the players - actual Manchester United 'supporters' who have just ignored him.

Honestly, I wouldn't have been too bothered if he'd not made any first team appearances this season, I'd still have used him but not as much, but the fact is that he has. It's got nothing to do with the goals that he scored.

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Well sorry if I like to use the WHOLE SQUAD of the team I support instead of just the first choice xi.

So do i. But im not gonna worry myself because Thomas Cruise' hair is a bit too dark

Originally Posted by Super-manc

I just think it's a lalalalalaeap creating a random player and sticking his name on the back of the shirt. The annoying thing is that it's volunteers who edit and give feedback on the players - actual Manchester United 'supporters' who have just ignored him.

And you think Macheda is the only player they have done that to? Nope.
You said it yourself. a by product of having a bunch of "fans" who havent got a clue.

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Honestly, I wouldn't have been too bothered if he'd not made any first team appearances this season, I'd still have used him but not as much, but the fact is that he has. It's got nothing to do with the goals that he scored.

Then you are the only manchester united supporter who can say that. You might even be the only person outside the club who knew his name before the villa game.

[savillbros]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

I just cant see the "he doesnt look real so i cant use him" attitude. seems pretty childish to me.

As people have pointed out, when the game was produced he was a nobody (and still is in my eyes) therefor he got a generic look. Then he scores one good goal and getlalalala by someone elses shot and everyone is toasting him and to top it all off getting worried because he doesnt look real in fifa 09.

Answer me this. If he hadnt played against Villa and Sunderland would we still be having this discussion? Would you still be worried about how he looks?

This is the only person that makes a decent argument on this thread, i can see where Supers coming from, but you gotta remember that their is more than 1 team then just Man Utd, lol, or not, they cant make every player as realistic and life-like, they have a year to produce a game, you gotta think of everything their improving, theirs a lot more than player height, they have the gameplay, they work with EVERYTHING, and it takes a long time, and tbh, EA do well to make it as good a game as it is, in a year, think of EVERYTHING they have to do in a year.

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by savillbros

This is the only person that makes a decent argument on this thread,

Thanks very much.

[Super-manc]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

So do i. But im not gonna worry myself because Thomas Cruise' hair is a bit too dark


And you think Macheda is the only player they have done that to? Nope.
You said it yourself. a by product of having a bunch of "fans" who havent got a clue.


Then you are the only manchester united supporter who can say that. You might even be the only person outside the club who knew his name before the villa game.

Height and weight make a lot of difference in FIFA, actually. Have you tried playing with him? It's nothing like him. To be fair though, when EA do make an effort, they do a bloody good job of it. I'm confident that it will be fixed in 2010, but it would be nice to have an end-of-season update like they had the February one.

I guess from this thread I was hoping that other people would name players from other teams who aren't made accurately (like Fat Ronaldo).

No, I'm not the only United supporter who can say that. Loads of supporters watch and keep up to date with the reserves.

Originally Posted by savillbros

This is the only person that makes a decent argument on this thread, i can see where Supers coming from, but you gotta remember that their is more than 1 team then just Man Utd, lol, or not, they cant make every player as realistic and life-like, they have a year to produce a game, you gotta think of everything their improving, theirs a lot more than player height, they have the gameplay, they work with EVERYTHING, and it takes a long time, and tbh, EA do well to make it as good a game as it is, in a year, think of EVERYTHING they have to do in a year.

I know, but still

[ChrisBFC]

How do you feel for us lower league fans, none of them look real. don't see us complaining.

Macheda was unknown when fifa came out, probably was still a school kid

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Height and weight make a lot of difference in FIFA, actually. Have you tried playing with him?

Refuse to touch united, i prefer to beat them, i rarely use arsenal nowadays too. 5* games are boring as hell.

Originally Posted by Super-manc

I guess from this thread I was hoping that other people would name players from other teams who aren't made accurately (like Fat Ronaldo).

Where did you ask people to do that?

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by ChrisBFC

How do you feel for us lower league fans, none of them look real. don't see us complaining.

Exactly. My Local club arent in the game, so i usually use aldershot who are just down the road.

[Super-manc]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

Refuse to touch united, i prefer to beat them, i rarely use arsenal nowadays too. 5* games are boring as hell.


Where did you ask people to do that?

True. I hate playing with 5* teams because all the abusers pick them. At least with lower star teams it's harder to abuse.

[HWick_Bluenose]

Agree with T-Mills-85 - one of the few guys on here whose posts make any sense and a positive contribution.

You should see some of the Birmingham players if you are concerned about how they look.....point is it's how they (or rather YOU) play.

This the the same as those who go on about boots and new strips and the colour of the blue at Stamford Bridge - WHO CARES! Better EA spend their time developing game play and fixing bugs

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by HWick_Bluenose

Agree with T-Mills-85 - one of the few guys on here whose posts make any sense and a positive contribution.

You should see some of the Birmingham players if you are concerned about how they look.....point is it's how they (or rather YOU) play.

This the the same as those who go on about boots and new strips and the colour of the blue at Stamford Bridge - WHO CARES! Better EA spend their time developing game play and fixing bugs

Guys please, im blushing .

Agree with your post though. More bugs fixed please. I do wonder how people notice some of the stuff they complain about. i tend to keep my eyes on the ball.

[daherlihy]

Originally Posted by Mickaldinho

Why on earth would EA make a better version of him, I am a Man Utd fan and he is lalalain lalalala!!!

I gotta agree too, and as another United fan.

[lyle_17]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

True. I hate playing with 5* teams because all the abusers pick them. At least with lower star teams it's harder to abuse.

Are Man United not a 5 star team? And does Macheda, the player in question not play for them? I think you are talking lalalalalalalala my friend. And I'd never heard of Macheda, and I bet you didn't either. And don't say I'm a fairweather fan. The only Italian I'd heard of was Daniele Petrucci.

[Cheeky Hobbit]

Macheda should at least get a boost, not a whole lot, bust just enough to be satisfactory

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by lyle_17

Are Man United not a 5 star team? And does Macheda, the player in question not play for them? I think you are talking lalalalalalalala my friend. And I'd never heard of Macheda, and I bet you didn't either. And don't say I'm a fairweather fan. The only Italian I'd heard of was Daniele Petrucci.

Well there you have it, a man utd fan that isnt afraid to say he hadn't heard of macheda before the villa game. Well done sir.

[Rusty]

Read the thread, cant be bothered commenting fully.

Agree with T-Mills posts.

[daherlihy]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

Well there you have it, a man utd fan that isnt afraid to say he hadn't heard of macheda before the villa game. Well done sir.

Ill add my name to that list as well... never heard of him until he scored!!

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by daherlihy

Ill add my name to that list as well... never heard of him until he scored!!

I don't think its anything to be ashamed of. The match of the day guys were as shocked as the rest of the country. I just find it hilarious that some man utd fans refuse to admit it.

[kubicaftw]

Originally Posted by DjShrimpsalad

Realistc

ah right, calling 1 of the best goals of the season very lucky is very realistic

[Rusty]

Originally Posted by kubicaftw

ah right, calling 1 of the best goals of the season very lucky is very realistic

Face it, he is a no-one. He popped up scored a good goal, now he back to obscurity. Unless he delivers week in week out, he will just be another loan signing for Plymouth, then move on to some league 2 side on a permanent deal.

[Smoooooochy]

Originally Posted by DjShrimpsalad

Your a complete muppet. You think EA should remake him just because you cba to wait until FIFA10? Hes a bad player, and had two 'very' lucky goals this season. No mancs knew about him before his goal against Villa, then they all hit up Wikipedia and now they think they are experts and want his stats to get a huge boost. Typical mancs, no sense of reality.

oh come on. 1 class goal and 1 fluke.

as a united fan he is still unproven imo.

[fumancu10]

so he scored two goals so us liverpool fans should be looking for n'gog el zhar and spering to be remaded i dont think so and the funny thing is man u might not even have him by fifa 10

[Rusty]

What?

[T-Mills-85]

Originally Posted by Rusty

What?

Rabble rabble rabble

[Rusty]

Originally Posted by T-Mills-85

Rabble rabble rabble

Deeh Dukka Dehhhhhhhhhh!!