Official PC Demo Feedback Thread - Page 4

miharuhk · 12-09-2008, 02:40 AM

Feedback: Little improvement in graphic but still far away from NG fifa
Gameplay is really suck just almost same as fifa 08. Game optimization is suck campared to COD4, crysis.
I will not buy the full ver fifa09 in PC. I would buy fifa 09 for xbox360 and PES2009 for PC.

miharuhk · 12-09-2008, 02:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rhipz

How can anyone say this demo is good. This demo is Fifa 08 with additional features. They haven't even bothered to texture the players properly, they added '3d grass' A very very poorly controlled Be A Pro and expect to excite us loyal pc players? How dare they. I am extremely polished, this 'demo' isn't even polished enough for a 'demonstration' of the game. They also try to excite us by adding 'widgets', Who the HELL, would look at a video of a Fifa game, hear the game has widgets and get excited, I really hope Developers look at this and realise they really need to start changing the whole PC version of Fifa altogether and not add 'new features' such as 3d Grass. The 3d Grass isn't even visible in some camera modes. Gameplay is very very poor, and I really prefer Fifa 08's gameplay to this lalalala. I have been buying a Fifa game for PC since 2003 and I have been staying loyal to EA sports hoping they will change the main dynamics of the game, but no, It's the same game dynamics from 2005. And they try to lie to us, saying they added 350 collision animations. What a load of BullS***. I tested Didier Drogba against a small player in many ways, and I see no difference to Fifa 08. Sham. Mouse controls are very difficult to understand and do not provide any enjoyment to me the player. If I were the PC developer I really would not release this. I would work on a revamped Next-Generation version on the PC, not using any Fifa 08 assets, or Fifa 2005 for that matter, and release Fifa 10 for next year. You may think, they might as well release it. But no, many other people like myself are experiencing the exact same woe's and you are losing customers. Excite us by scrapping Fifa 09 altogether and release a new Fifa next year. We can wait, if your a loyal fan like me, then you can wait. Take my serious advice EA. Scrap Fifa 09. It's not working. Redo Fifa on the PC and take that demo piece of lalalala offline.

Overall: 0/10.

Agui-Albert Mansilla.

I can't agree more

AlaaEG88 · 12-09-2008, 02:42 AM

Anyone wants to have some AA:
Performance/Controller issues

mitio · 12-09-2008, 03:14 AM

Under the hood, FIFA09 is the same as 08 when playing with the Keyboard.

But, man, do I love the mouse! I really liked FIFA08, and 09 is like 08, but with absolute freedom of passing and moving.

You can put the ball anywhere you want and you can tell players making runs exactly where to go! Did you hate crossing in FIFA08 like I did? The mouse allows for precise crossing - you can easily put the ball just ahead of the onrushing attacker, but still far enough from the ‘keeper to allow for a clinical finish. I also think that the player will attempt to put the ball exactly where the mouse is pointing when shooting. I’m still not sure of this though, as I haven’t played enough to really test it, but I did hit a post I was deliberately aiming for several times.

I sense a Semi-Pro difficulty level. Lets hope World Class is better than in 08.

Quote:

FIFA09 needs a decent champions celebration for when you win a league.
And maybe a different one for cup competitions. Like the team walking up the steps of Wembley. And it should last for 2-3 minutes.

Yes it does! I fully agree.

Waddaa13 · 12-09-2008, 04:07 AM

why referee & lineman dose not reacte with the game
they only look to the ball they hands dosen't move to clearify the foul or offside
its a big bug from fifa 2007
i hope u fix it

and also there is some bugs people here talked about i wish EA get every thing fixed

Digw33d · 12-09-2008, 05:23 AM

i found something when i was playing the other day and i think it's a bug...u know those cutscenes where, after a player of one team makes a hard tackle against an adversary, players of the other team will come, and start arguing with the player that committed the fault? well...the players that were arguing were actually of the same team - Chelsea - it was Ballack and Lampard ( he committed the fault on the opposing player )

christie07081993 · 12-09-2008, 06:46 AM

This Is A Serious Bug!!!!
Notice That After Half Time, The Players Of The Leading Team Shows Such Gestures As They've Won The Match But This Is Not Correct! They Should At The Most Talk To Each Other And Quietly Walk Off The Pitch After Half Time Not More Than That. I'm Really Annoyed By This.
There Are Some Lighting Problems Also.if A Player Faces Away From The Sun, How Come His Forehead Will Reflect Light Of His Sweat????
Ea Please Do Answer These Questions Otherwise The Game's Gonna Get A Serious Setback.

Digw33d · 12-09-2008, 06:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by christie07081993

This Is A Serious Bug!!!!
Notice That After Half Time, The Players Of The Leading Team Shows Such Gestures As They've Won The Match But This Is Not Correct! They Should At The Most Talk To Each Other And Quietly Walk Off The Pitch After Half Time Not More Than That. I'm Really Annoyed By This.
There Are Some Lighting Problems Also.if A Player Faces Away From The Sun, How Come His Forehead Will Reflect Light Of His Sweat????
Ea Please Do Answer These Questions Otherwise The Game's Gonna Get A Serious Setback.

I think that's only gonna be in the demo

Jahaanpana · 12-09-2008, 07:05 AM

TO rhipz,
You know what dude , u are a piece of s*** and you sound like an ***... what do you know about making a f***** game anyways .... a moron like you wouldnt make a difference to the game and community one bit and you have the nerve of talking so much............

Let me say s**t , time and again hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique. The game is independently developed and much more user-freindly... The console versions are only gonna last maybe max 4 years and its versions are not worth becoming a port.

Remember i am not talking about the animations or physics .. i am talking about the game play that is stunted... Testers checking a fifa console game, always consider it a more rigid game, it doesnt allow you to play whatever style youd like to play, on ther other hand , Fifa PC offers you limitless styles to play and adapt.

The process of converting FIFA pC to next gen might be slow, but once its there then there is no console that can overcome it ..... SO please stop whining for a port
( PES has sc****d its game with this porting lalalala )
Fifa PC is impressive and has a lot of future
As for you and your lalalala post
Quit fifa and play some real football
Do you need a demo for that !!!!!
YOU stupid piece of s***

PS: A great job hossack , being a tester myself i don know the constraints of this game and kind of effort your put in..... EA is reaching there i am waiting

istanboY · 12-09-2008, 07:19 AM

For me,

The Good: Gameplay always comes first for me. To be honest gameplay is really better than 08. Player models are good. Collision system is also good and realistic. And of course at last far better gfx. Game Menus and statistics are masterpiece!

The Bad: Those 92 years old CUTSCENES!!!!!!!!!! They are rap.ng the realism of the game. Nets are horrrrrrrrrrrrible. What is that stupid crowd doing with the sweet gfx? The ball is a basketball ball

Referees are brainless. Cpu AI is not enough neither. They still don't know anything about wingplay. There's no untucked shirts. No quick throw inns, goal kicks. No visible managers or subs.

Looks like the bad is rap.ng the Good. As unfortunately Pes2009 will r.pe Fifa09 on PCs this year again.

KG14 · 12-09-2008, 07:20 AM

Well, my download finally finished, and here is what I have to say.

The graphics are very good in my opinion, the gameplay is also good.
Personally, I didn't like the controls, so I modified them to the FIFA 08 controls - no problem there.

The game was slightly choppy, although that could just be my computer.

There is an observation that I have to make about the match I played: I was ahead at the half-time break. And in the half-time cutscene, I could see my players running around all over the place as if they had won and the game was over! Very strange.

Also: Why was the Keeper Control removed? I really liked that feature. I can't tell if the Keeper AI has been made more Natural or if the Keepers just got out of bed on the wrong side, because scoring (For and Against) was very easy.

That's what I have to say.

fulcj001 · 12-09-2008, 07:28 AM

the difficulty was probably automatically on amateur

vulturu0707 · 12-09-2008, 07:40 AM

hmm this is a nice demo but i have a big problem with my gamepad, or this demo have o problem with it. i have a trhustmaster dual trigger 2 in 1 and it works fine witu fifa08 and euro 2008 and also this demo is recognising my gamepad but i can't set the buttons for trough pass ,slidling tackle ,standing tackle...have a look

what can i do?

christie07081993 · 12-09-2008, 07:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by KG14

Well, my download finally finished, and here is what I have to say.

The graphics are very good in my opinion, the gameplay is also good.
Personally, I didn't like the controls, so I modified them to the FIFA 08 controls - no problem there.

The game was slightly choppy, although that could just be my computer.

There is an observation that I have to make about the match I played: I was ahead at the half-time break. And in the half-time cutscene, I could see my players running around all over the place as if they had won and the game was over! Very strange.

Also: Why was the Keeper Control removed? I really liked that feature. I can't tell if the Keeper AI has been made more Natural or if the Keepers just got out of bed on the wrong side, because scoring (For and Against) was very easy.

That's what I have to say.

DUDA THE GK CONTROL HASN'T BEEN REMOVED JUST PRESS RIGHT SHIFT INSTEAD OF THE LEFT ONE.THAT DOESN'T WORK!!!!

bobinho23 · 12-09-2008, 08:49 AM

i just encountered a bug... i scored a goal and when the game continued it was a goal kick ...

Subra · 12-09-2008, 08:49 AM

The gameplay is improved,graphics are better than 08 but not good enough.Keepers are really hard to beat and defenses are better.However,when you pass to any player,i feel that he moves the ball too forward and the defense takes it.Be a pro third person camera was good.player models looked better too.Good AI.Not bad for PC,but it can be improved further.

PlayFifajo · 12-09-2008, 09:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jahaanpana

TO rhipz,
You know what dude , u are a piece of s*** and you sound like an ***... what do you know about making a f***** game anyways .... a moron like you wouldnt make a difference to the game and community one bit and you have the nerve of talking so much............

Let me say s**t , time and again hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique. The game is independently developed and much more user-freindly... The console versions are only gonna last maybe max 4 years and its versions are not worth becoming a port.

Remember i am not talking about the animations or physics .. i am talking about the game play that is stunted... Testers checking a fifa console game, always consider it a more rigid game, it doesnt allow you to play whatever style youd like to play, on ther other hand , Fifa PC offers you limitless styles to play and adapt.

The process of converting FIFA pC to next gen might be slow, but once its there then there is no console that can overcome it ..... SO please stop whining for a port
( PES has sc****d its game with this porting lalalala )
Fifa PC is impressive and has a lot of future
As for you and your lalalala post
Quit fifa and play some real football
Do you need a demo for that !!!!!
YOU stupid piece of s***

PS: A great job hossack , being a tester myself i don know the constraints of this game and kind of effort your put in..... EA is reaching there i am waiting

You fan boy calm down , first go watch a football match and then go play FIFA 09 and you will say then : "oh what the... is this...".FIFA 09 doesn't simulate a football game.Almost nothing ain't real , where have you seen refferies which only run without picking up the flag, or crowd made from paper(horrible) , the grass uncuted and painted is so big i can't believe ( see the xbox360 version there is a real grass ), the players moves are so UNREALISTICS, they are ROBOTS ( who say the contrary didin't saw a football game in his life) .FIFA is an arcade game.And about PES , is an arcade too because there aren't licensed teams , and when i play it i can't feel like i play a real game, but better than FIFA on PC anyway.The only game game which almost simulate football is FIFA 09 on xbox360/ps3.

GDM184 · 12-09-2008, 09:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jahaanpana

TO rhipz,
You know what dude , u are a piece of s*** and you sound like an ***... what do you know about making a f***** game anyways .... a moron like you wouldnt make a difference to the game and community one bit and you have the nerve of talking so much............

Let me say s**t , time and again hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique. The game is independently developed and much more user-freindly... The console versions are only gonna last maybe max 4 years and its versions are not worth becoming a port.

Remember i am not talking about the animations or physics .. i am talking about the game play that is stunted... Testers checking a fifa console game, always consider it a more rigid game, it doesnt allow you to play whatever style youd like to play, on ther other hand , Fifa PC offers you limitless styles to play and adapt.

The process of converting FIFA pC to next gen might be slow, but once its there then there is no console that can overcome it ..... SO please stop whining for a port
( PES has sc****d its game with this porting lalalala )
Fifa PC is impressive and has a lot of future
As for you and your lalalala post
Quit fifa and play some real football
Do you need a demo for that !!!!!
YOU stupid piece of s***

PS: A great job hossack , being a tester myself i don know the constraints of this game and kind of effort your put in..... EA is reaching there i am waiting

You are surely a fifa fanboy. How can you say that fifa 09 is better than pes2008!?! Yes, it may be a port, but it's way better. If fifa 09 pc would be a port, it would be better than pes. And I don't think that swearing to a person will convert him to a fanboy, neither will defend your fifa, nor will change his idea of the game. He was only saying what he thinks.
"hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique"... yes, it's unique, in it's poor quality, at least for me.

PlayFifajo · 12-09-2008, 09:18 AM

"hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique"... yes, it's unique, in it's poor quality, at least for me.

Nice said.It's unique a stupid game.They made a game "unique" when all PC players want a game like on Xbox360.

Baker011 · 12-09-2008, 09:21 AM

Ok guys, calm down please. Lets try to avoid personal flame wars.

Keep the constructive feedback coming

Becks7P · 12-09-2008, 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by vulturu0707

hmm this is a nice demo but i have a big problem with my gamepad, or this demo have o problem with it. i have a trhustmaster dual trigger 2 in 1 and it works fine witu fifa08 and euro 2008 and also this demo is recognising my gamepad but i can't set the buttons for trough pass ,slidling tackle ,standing tackle...have a look

what can i do?

I have got the same problem, as have many. Is anyone gonna find a solution to this ? EA better do something about it.

inteus2006 · 12-09-2008, 09:30 AM

The game it's a little bit unreal because I shoot from 40 m with ronaldinho or kaka and i score under the crossbar

(hope the goalkepers will be better at world class or legendery)

PlayFifajo · 12-09-2008, 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EAUK_Baker011

Ok guys, calm down please. Lets try to avoid personal flame wars.

Keep the constructive feedback coming

Who will give to producers our feedback , because i see they don't get our feedback or they don't want to listen to our feedback.In FIFA 10 we will see how they listened to our feedback.

miharuhk · 12-09-2008, 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PlayFifajo

Who will give to producers our feedback , because i see they don't get our feedback or they don't want to listen to our feedback.In FIFA 10 we will see how they listened to our feedback.

I don't think they will listen. Let's remember how PAUL HOSSACK try his best on PC fifa in recently year

Brcln930 · 12-09-2008, 10:26 AM

EA, wha ta lalalala controll keyboard buttons?! Make it like in 08!!! It is very lalalala that button one button is cross and other button is taqling!! in fifa 08 is was only one button!!!

12-09-2008, 04:07 AM	#80 (permalink)
Waddaa13 Rookie Join Date: Mar 2007 Location: Egypt Age: 22 Gender: Male Posts: 235	why referee & lineman dose not reacte with the game they only look to the ball they hands dosen't move to clearify the foul or offside its a big bug from fifa 2007 i hope u fix it and also there is some bugs people here talked about i wish EA get every thing fixed Last edited by Waddaa13; 12-09-2008 at 04:10 AM..

12-09-2008, 06:46 AM	#82 (permalink)
christie07081993 Rookie Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 248	This Is A Serious Bug!!!! Notice That After Half Time, The Players Of The Leading Team Shows Such Gestures As They've Won The Match But This Is Not Correct! They Should At The Most Talk To Each Other And Quietly Walk Off The Pitch After Half Time Not More Than That. I'm Really Annoyed By This. There Are Some Lighting Problems Also.if A Player Faces Away From The Sun, How Come His Forehead Will Reflect Light Of His Sweat???? Ea Please Do Answer These Questions Otherwise The Game's Gonna Get A Serious Setback. __________________

12-09-2008, 07:19 AM	#85 (permalink)
istanboY Forum Regular Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Istanbul Age: 24 Posts: 589	For me, The Good: Gameplay always comes first for me. To be honest gameplay is really better than 08. Player models are good. Collision system is also good and realistic. And of course at last far better gfx. Game Menus and statistics are masterpiece! The Bad: Those 92 years old CUTSCENES!!!!!!!!!! They are rap.ng the realism of the game. Nets are horrrrrrrrrrrrible. What is that stupid crowd doing with the sweet gfx? The ball is a basketball ball Referees are brainless. Cpu AI is not enough neither. They still don't know anything about wingplay. There's no untucked shirts. No quick throw inns, goal kicks. No visible managers or subs. Looks like the bad is rap.ng the Good. As unfortunately Pes2009 will r.pe Fifa09 on PCs this year again. __________________ Last edited by istanboY; 12-09-2008 at 07:45 AM..

12-09-2008, 07:28 AM	#87 (permalink)
fulcj001 Forum Regular Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 547	the difficulty was probably automatically on amateur __________________

12-09-2008, 07:40 AM	#88 (permalink)
vulturu0707 Rookie Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 15	my gamepad hmm this is a nice demo but i have a big problem with my gamepad, or this demo have o problem with it. i have a trhustmaster dual trigger 2 in 1 and it works fine witu fifa08 and euro 2008 and also this demo is recognising my gamepad but i can't set the buttons for trough pass ,slidling tackle ,standing tackle...have a look what can i do?

12-09-2008, 02:40 AM	#76 (permalink)
miharuhk Rookie Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 113	Feedback: Little improvement in graphic but still far away from NG fifa Gameplay is really suck just almost same as fifa 08. Game optimization is suck campared to COD4, crysis. I will not buy the full ver fifa09 in PC. I would buy fifa 09 for xbox360 and PES2009 for PC.

12-09-2008, 02:42 AM	#78 (permalink)
AlaaEG88 Forum Regular Join Date: May 2007 Location: Cairo, Egypt Age: 21 Posts: 522	Anyone wants to have some AA: Performance/Controller issues

12-09-2008, 05:23 AM	#81 (permalink)
Digw33d Rookie Join Date: Feb 2008 Age: 21 Posts: 158	i found something when i was playing the other day and i think it's a bug...u know those cutscenes where, after a player of one team makes a hard tackle against an adversary, players of the other team will come, and start arguing with the player that committed the fault? well...the players that were arguing were actually of the same team - Chelsea - it was Ballack and Lampard ( he committed the fault on the opposing player )

12-09-2008, 07:05 AM	#84 (permalink)
Jahaanpana Rookie Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 97	TO rhipz, You know what dude , u are a piece of s* and you sound like an ... what do you know about making a f** game anyways .... a moron like you wouldnt make a difference to the game and community one bit and you have the nerve of talking so much............ Let me say st , time and again hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique. The game is independently developed and much more user-freindly... The console versions are only gonna last maybe max 4 years and its versions are not worth becoming a port. Remember i am not talking about the animations or physics .. i am talking about the game play that is stunted... Testers checking a fifa console game, always consider it a more rigid game, it doesnt allow you to play whatever style youd like to play, on ther other hand , Fifa PC offers you limitless styles to play and adapt. The process of converting FIFA pC to next gen might be slow, but once its there then there is no console that can overcome it ..... SO please stop whining for a port ( PES has sc**d its game with this porting lalalala ) Fifa PC is impressive and has a lot of future As for you and your lalalala post Quit fifa and play some real football Do you need a demo for that !!!!! YOU stupid piece of s* PS: A great job hossack , being a tester myself i don know the constraints of this game and kind of effort your put in..... EA is reaching there i am waiting

12-09-2008, 07:20 AM	#86 (permalink)
KG14 Rookie Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: Guatemala Age: 16 Posts: 130	Well, my download finally finished, and here is what I have to say. The graphics are very good in my opinion, the gameplay is also good. Personally, I didn't like the controls, so I modified them to the FIFA 08 controls - no problem there. The game was slightly choppy, although that could just be my computer. There is an observation that I have to make about the match I played: I was ahead at the half-time break. And in the half-time cutscene, I could see my players running around all over the place as if they had won and the game was over! Very strange. Also: Why was the Keeper Control removed? I really liked that feature. I can't tell if the Keeper AI has been made more Natural or if the Keepers just got out of bed on the wrong side, because scoring (For and Against) was very easy. That's what I have to say.

12-09-2008, 08:49 AM	#90 (permalink)
bobinho23 Rookie Join Date: Mar 2008 Location: hell Age: 24 Posts: 190	i just encountered a bug... i scored a goal and when the game continued it was a goal kick ...

12-09-2008, 08:49 AM	#91 (permalink)
Subra Banned Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 39	The gameplay is improved,graphics are better than 08 but not good enough.Keepers are really hard to beat and defenses are better.However,when you pass to any player,i feel that he moves the ball too forward and the defense takes it.Be a pro third person camera was good.player models looked better too.Good AI.Not bad for PC,but it can be improved further.

12-09-2008, 09:18 AM	#94 (permalink)
PlayFifajo Banned Join Date: Sep 2007 Posts: 508	"hossack and his people are trying to make the pC game unique"... yes, it's unique, in it's poor quality, at least for me. Nice said.It's unique a stupid game.They made a game "unique" when all PC players want a game like on Xbox360.

12-09-2008, 09:21 AM	#95 (permalink)
Baker011 Forum Guru Join Date: Aug 2007 Location: In a galaxy far far away.... Age: 27 Gender: Male Posts: 1,690 Blog Entries: 6	Ok guys, calm down please. Lets try to avoid personal flame wars. Keep the constructive feedback coming __________________ EA Football World Profile Where is steve?

12-09-2008, 09:30 AM	#97 (permalink)
inteus2006 Rookie Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Ploiesti Romania Posts: 84	The game it's a little bit unreal because I shoot from 40 m with ronaldinho or kaka and i score under the crossbar (hope the goalkepers will be better at world class or legendery)

12-09-2008, 10:26 AM	#100 (permalink)
Brcln930 Forum Regular Join Date: Nov 2007 Location: Russian Federation, Moscow Age: 23 Posts: 705	EA, wha ta lalalala controll keyboard buttons?! Make it like in 08!!! It is very lalalala that button one button is cross and other button is taqling!! in fifa 08 is was only one button!!! __________________ Hala Madrid!!! In Florentino Perez we trust!!! IL FENOMENO R9 Brcln930_CR9_GOD FIFA 10 Online (PC)