Gerrard Pique

[iArshaviin]

Most overrated defender on the game

[The_Amazing_Goal]

na, vidic is more overated.

[Senor_Smurf]

He's only an 82.... Barca have 4 better CBs as it is.

[Ryzee25]

Exactly, he is for some reason quicker and stronger than drogba!!!! What the lala!?!?!?!

[The Metal Moth]

Vidic is the most overrated, hes a shell of a defender since being turned inside out by torres. Like evra and lennon

[Senor_Smurf]

Originally Posted by The Metal Moth

Vidic is the most overrated, hes a shell of a defender since being turned inside out by torres. Like evra and lennon

Torres is Vidic's Achilles heel. Evra is pretty consistent, so I can't say that their quite bad or overrated.

[The Metal Moth]

Evra and vidic are both overrated, Evra just a tad and vidic massively, 82 at best. best CB IN THE WORLD!?.. riiiight

[FifaFreaky]

Howcome Ribery has a finishing of 81 and long shots 77? Are u freakin kidding me or what?

[AXERTYRE]

Lol shut up you yid, Evra puked all over Lennon last game, he had to switch over to the left because he was scared of Evra, why didn't you mention that?

[The Metal Moth]

Originally Posted by AXERTYRE

Lol shut up you yid, Evra puked all over Lennon last game, he had to switch over to the left because he was scared of Evra, why didn't you mention that?

Im going to go out on a limb here and say your a glory hunter.

This isnt because your a Utd fan, your not all glory hunters just a few.

However you clearly dont pay any attention to football other than the results you find out from your few true football fan friends.

I think this because not only do you think a tottenham fan would find the word yid offensive (I am a yid and Im bloody proud of it) but also you seem to think evra does a good job of handling lennon? Riiiiiighht, btw he never moved to the left due to evra but yeah think what you like, even my utd fan friends (they watch football you see) agree lennon is to evra what torres is to vidic.

Muppet

[b-l-i-n-g-a-h]

Originally Posted by The_Amazing_Goal

na, vidic is more overated.

you have never seen vidic play in real life, otherwise you wouldnt have writ this post

[The Metal Moth]

Originally Posted by b-l-i-n-g-a-h

you have never seen vidic play in real life, otherwise you wouldnt have writ this post

I think its BECAUSE he has that he WROTE that post.

[b-l-i-n-g-a-h]

Evra and vidic are both overrated, Evra just a tad and vidic massively, 82 at best. best CB IN THE WORLD!?.. riiiighthe plays for a team that WON the champions league, and that got to the champions league final, how the lalalala is he over rated

[michaelmanutd27]

Gerard pique is waaaaaayy too good!!!! Most overated player ever!!!!!

Beats drogba nearly all the time!

[Roonaldos]

Vidic hasnt played well since being destroyed by Torres last season. I would of said 89 until then, now about 86. However Puyol should be 82 max. Pique should go up a point but have his strength and speed toned down. Drogba should have 99 strength. Evra should be 85 apart from against Liverpool and Spurs last season he was brilliant and is the best leftback, ahead of Cole. Terry is overrated. He should be 86 and if Ferdinand and Vidic get back on form and stay fit they have the right ratings. Casillas is overrated he isnt playing very well and should be 88 and Cesar 89.

[b-l-i-n-g-a-h]

Originally Posted by The Metal Moth

I think its BECAUSE he has that he WROTE that post.

that just didnt make sense...

[The Metal Moth]

Originally Posted by b-l-i-n-g-a-h

Evra and vidic are both overrated, Evra just a tad and vidic massively, 82 at best. best CB IN THE WORLD!?.. riiiighthe plays for a team that WON the champions league, and that got to the champions league final, how the lalalala is he over rated

So he plays for man utd so hes good?

and you are saying other people DONT WANT FOOTBALL?

You fool...

[The Metal Moth]

Originally Posted by b-l-i-n-g-a-h

that just didnt make sense...

Let me simplify for you.

• You say he hasnt seen vidic play thats why he thinks hes overrated
• I say its because he HAS seen him play that he thinks that, cus ive seen him and thats what I think
• I also corrected where you said 'writ' and you meant 'wrote'

Understand?

[Roonaldos]

Originally Posted by iArshaviin

Most overrated defender on the game

i thought pique was better in 09. i always played him and he was unstoppable, i used to one-two with him to the edge of the area and score, or if i really needed a goal i played him centre forward. he was ridiculously good. i havent tried him up front in 10 but something tells me it wont work, heading isnt great any more.

[afroCHRIS]

Originally Posted by b-l-i-n-g-a-h

he plays for a team that WON the champions league, and that got to the champions league final, how the lalalala is he over rated

It's about the player, not the team. And the player is overrated. The team is not, but the player is.

[The Metal Moth]

Originally Posted by afroCHRIS

It's about the player, not the team. And the player is overrated. The team is not, but the player is.

A man with sense.

[afroCHRIS]

Originally Posted by The Metal Moth

A man with sense.

Correct!

[Ryzee25]

Lennon destroyed evra in a fa cup tie or was it carling cup last season

[VEO15]

FULL CASTROL RANKINGS | Castrol Football | Official Sponsor 2010 FIFA World Cup™ South Africa

Best defender in the top 5 European leagues, apparently. Vidic best outside Barcelona, known as 5th.

[michaelmanutd27]

this thread is called gerrard pique!!

so why is everyone speaking about vidic and evra being overated just because thye had some bad games. messi and ronaldo have bad games, do they get called overated? no.

PIQUE IS DEFO OVERATED!!!