Manchester United Ratings

[KyleR93-Mufc]

This is just my opinion and what I think would be fair ratings.

Keepers

Van der Sar 84
Foster 80
Kuszczak 76

Defenders

Neville 79
Ferdinand 87
Vidic 88
Evra 84
Evans 80
Brown 80
O'Shea 79
Rafael 75
Fabio 71

Midfielders

Nani 82
Valencia 81
Scholes 84
Carrick 84
Anderson 82
Giggs 82
Park 80
Gibson 72
Fletcher 83
Hargreaves 82 (Live Season will make him lower)

Forwards

Rooney 87
Berbatov 85
Owen 80
Welbeck 75
Macheda 75

[kyro7]

At the moment, Fletcher is playing better than Scholes, I think you have underrated Valencia aswell in my opinion, and I think Rooney should be 88 tbh.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by kyro7

At the moment, Fletcher is playing better than Scholes, I think you have underrated Valencia aswell in my opinion, and I think Rooney should be 88 tbh.

Im being realistic here Fletcher wont be higher than Scholes, I just cant see EA doing that... Valencia maybe 1 or 2 higher yes and unfortunately Rooney never seems to get above 87

Overall, minor differences here and there.

[Ni-Crusader]

Good ratings although I'd have Carrick about 80.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by Ni-Crusader

Good ratings although I'd have Carrick about 80.

i dont think he should be that low... at least 82. I find that non-united fans dont rate him and I can sort of see why because he plays consitently well but does not get noticed. i think this year he has a chance to prove himself and will definately be in the World Cup squad etc.

[X360ADDICT]

Here's what I think
> - Stay as you suggested
^ - go up
v - go down

Keepers

Van der Sar 84 >
Foster 80 >
Kuszczak 76 ^

Defenders

Neville 79 >
Ferdinand 87 ^
Vidic 88 ^
Evra 84 ^
Evans 80 >
Brown 80 >
O'Shea 79 >
Rafael 75 v
Fabio 71 ^

Midfielders

Nani 82 v
Valencia 81 ^
Scholes 84 >
Carrick 84 >
Anderson 82 v
Giggs 82 >
Park 80 ^
Gibson 72 ^
Fletcher 83 >
Hargreaves 82 (Live Season will make him lower) true

Forwards

Rooney 87 ^
Berbatov 85 >
Owen 80 v
Welbeck 75 >
Macheda 75>

[kyro7]

Originally Posted by KyleR93-Mufc

Im being realistic here Fletcher wont be higher than Scholes, I just cant see EA doing that... Valencia maybe 1 or 2 higher yes and unfortunately Rooney never seems to get above 87

Overall, minor differences here and there.

You're being realistic but you said it was your opinion and in my opinion as a overall player Rooney is as good as anyone bar Messi and Ronaldo in my opinion therefore I think he deserves 88.

And I think Valencia should be 83, but I can't guarantee that, that's basing on what I have seen from Valencia at Wigan, United, and his country, he has been great.

Fletcher is once again one of the most unerrated players in the world, he makes a big difference to the team, if we had him playing in Rome against Barcelona I don't think they would have passed around are midfield the way they did, Fletcher is key against other good midfielders and tbh going forward he aint bad too.

That's my opinion.

[United_fan656]

Yeh i agree that carrick should be about 82, and all ratings are very good hope it comes out like that.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

these are all pre live season and go off how they performed last season aswell as the games this season.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by kyro7

You're being realistic but you said it was your opinion and in my opinion as a overall player Rooney is as good as anyone bar Messi and Ronaldo in my opinion therefore I think he deserves 88.

And I think Valencia should be 83, but I can't guarantee that, that's basing on what I have seen from Valencia at Wigan, United, and his country, he has been great.

Fletcher is once again one of the most unerrated players in the world, he makes a big difference to the team, if we had him playing in Rome against Barcelona I don't think they would have passed around are midfield the way they did, Fletcher is key against other good midfielders and tbh going forward he aint bad too.

That's my opinion.

I agree totally... but its up to EA.

Btw nice sig its looks class!

[kyro7]

Originally Posted by KyleR93-Mufc

I agree totally... but its up to EA.

Btw nice sig its looks class!

Yeah I hope EA get it right.

Thanks.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by kyro7

Yeah I hope EA get it right.

Thanks.

Yeah and with no Ronaldo, Rooney and the other players ratings should improve slightly.

[kyro7]

Originally Posted by KyleR93-Mufc

Yeah and with no Ronaldo, Rooney and the other players ratings should improve slightly.

Yeah, I think Rooney has been in Ronaldo's shadow for some time, I know Ronaldo scored plenty of goals for us, and he will be missed, but Rooney is such a difference in every game, and he has got off to a flyer this season, if he keeps it up, he could easily be battling for the golden boot.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by kyro7

Yeah, I think Rooney has been in Ronaldo's shadow for some time, I know Ronaldo scored plenty of goals for us, and he will be missed, but Rooney is such a difference in every game, and he has got off to a flyer this season, if he keeps it up, he could easily be battling for the golden boot.

I have always thought Rooney is our best player as Ronaldo never performed when Rooney did not play. He will be able to prove that now.

[abomufc108]

My ratings which i think are fair
in bold= Important rating



Goal Keepers

Van der Sar 84
Foster 76
Kuszczak 76

Defenders

Neville 78
Ferdinand 86
Vidic 88
Evra 85
Evans 81
Brown 78
O'Shea 79
Rafael 75
Fabio 71

Midfielders

Nani 81
Valencia 80 (Great pace tho)
Scholes 82
Carrick 83
Anderson 80 (But should have a good growth in MM)
Giggs 83 (84 if played in the middle)
Park 78
Gibson 72
Fletcher 82
Hargreaves 84 (Our best midfielder even when he is not fit)

Forwards

Rooney 88
Berbatov 85
Owen 79
Welbeck 75
Macheda 73 (too early to rate him 75)

[tabmax]

My opinion:

GK

Van der sar - 86

Foster - 80

Kuszczak - 78

Rafael - 76

Fabio - 74

Def:

Neville - 79

Brown - 80

Vidic - 87

Evra - 85

Rio - 86

O'shea - 81

Mid:

Carrick - 84

Giggs - 85 (even though he's old but still a legend)

Scholes - 84

Fletcher - 81

Anderson - 82

Park - 79

Forward:

Rooney - 88

Berbatov - 86

Nani - 85

Valencia - 81

Owen - 80

[kyro7]

Fletcher 81? I just don't get it.

[Strange Pirate]

No way is Foster 80 nor Scholes 82. Scholes should be 79 and Foster 76.

[kyro7]

Originally Posted by Strange Pirate

No way is Foster 80 nor Scholes 82. Scholes should be 79 and Foster 76.

There is no way Scholes should be 79 he should be about 82/83.

He can still control a game better than alot of central midfielders.

[KyleR93-Mufc]

Originally Posted by Strange Pirate

No way is Foster 80 nor Scholes 82. Scholes should be 79 and Foster 76.

Just leave.

[EAUK_Aurora]

[Moved to Database Discussion]

[Strange Pirate]

Shut up you butt plunderer. How is Ben "the drop" Foster deserving of a very good rating? He just isn't. And Scholes has been past it for atleast 2 seasons. Not only 2 ratings lower than Iniesta.

[AXERTYRE]

Originally Posted by Strange Pirate

No way is Foster 80 nor Scholes 82. Scholes should be 79 and Foster 76.

Scholes is too good to be 79, in fact if you check the his stats on Fifa 09, you can see EA underate some of his attributes to lower his overall rating like volley and vision. He should be 83 at least.

[Strange Pirate]

But the guy is past it completely. There's no way that a quality midfielder like Fletcher should be lower than a guy living off past greatness.

[tabmax]

Rooney really deserves to be 88 this season if not atleast 87.