Manchester United Ratings

[SwpR]

haha lol. Im probably one of the least bias reds out there. Look at the squad anderson 80? berbaflop 85 or is it 86? rooney 87? o'shea 80?

Hows that not overated, anderson is the understated flop of the club a new kleberson if you like, berbatov is like the striking equivalent of juan sebastian veron a few good touches and pieces of genuis but all in all a player that falls short. Now dont get me wrong rooneys a great striker but as good as villa (who went on a 20game national scoring streak) and better than forlan (who was the pichichi YET AGAIN) please.
And john oshea, good utility player but has zero talent yet he gets the same rating as glen johnson (im pretty sure john is 80, if not then im sorry). agree 100%. Anderson is good but not 80 good, Berba is the biggest bust I've seen. Should be a 78 al he can do is make miracle goes once a month tahts it. he sucks. O'Shea is a 78 not 80, but I think Rooney got robbed on his strenght/aggression, he gets pushed off the ball TOO much in Fifa. Also, Carrick is too high. So is Nani, he straight out SUCKS lalala. Can't shoot, can't cross, can't run an attack effectively hodls onto the ball for 10 seconds then dances before he loses it.

[Super-manc]

2 very childish posts above, I won't waste my time trying to convince you otherwise.

[Megaman1646]

useless nonsense the ratings are rated after the 2008-2009 season obviously, and i think they are pretty accurate to me

[kop2k8]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

2 very childish posts above, I won't waste my time trying to convince you otherwise.

Your calling ME childish go look in the mirror.

[Super-manc]

Yes, I'm calling you childish... looking in the mirror... nope not a child.

[kop2k8]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Yes, I'm calling you childish... looking in the mirror... nope not a child.

Big difference of being a child and being childish, just though the way you post you might be under 13 but well I guess its your mental state then

silly getting into an arguement to someone whos ignorant to the truth, I went into detail who was overated . When you juxtapose my comments to yours you'll see whos childish.

[Super-manc]

A lot of people on here said I seem about 30 by the way I post. Just shows the decline in British education these days but that's not the point. You say "silly getting into an argument with someone who won't accept the truth;" go back a few posts and I talked about how I didn't see the point in arguing with someone who believes that his opinion is fact (Rafa, is that you?) and therefore refuses to consider otherwise, I think that's fair enough, don't you?

[kop2k8]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

A lot of people on here said I seem about 30 by the way I post. Just shows the decline in British education these days but that's not the point. You say "silly getting into an argument with someone who won't accept the truth;" go back a few posts and I talked about how I didn't see the point in arguing with someone who believes that his opinion is fact (Rafa, is that you?) and therefore refuses to consider otherwise, I think that's fair enough, don't you?

Decline in british education, so what uni do you go to or are getting into?

I never said it was a categoric fact, it was all in my opinion you just immaturely laughed it off. Posting like a 30 year old doesnt mean your mature mate, you just seem very touchy on the subject of manchester united with any liverpool fan, you have a scouse fobia to say the least.

[DANTE_XBOX]

[QUOTE=KyleR93-Mufc;11208851]This is just my opinion and what I think would be fair ratings.


Nani 82





nani sucks giggs and valencia rape him

[kop2k8]

scholes and o'shea are the ones to lalalalala about, I mean 80 and 84, o'shea is a MR dependable but hes not anything close to glen johnson or rafinha as a RB.

Scholes great player 4 years ago but he doesnt exactly do anything nowadays, so what he pings about 3 40yards in one game but thats all, his shootings disappeared and he still cant defend. I cant for the life of me understand how hes rated more than nasri,sneijder,barry and ireland.

[Super-manc]

scholes and o'shea are the ones to lalalalala about, I mean 80 and 84, o'shea is a MR dependable but hes not anything close to glen johnson or rafinha as a RB.

Scholes great player 4 years ago but he doesnt exactly do anything nowadays, so what he pings about 3 40yards in one game but thats all, his shootings disappeared and he still cant defend. I cant for the life of me understand how hes rated more than nasri,sneijder,barry and ireland.

Who the lalalala is Rafinha? (Rhetorical question, I do know who Rafinha is)

And Glen Johnson... a £17m price tag doesn't justify a 80+ rating alone. Going on this season I don't know how you can say any of your defenders deserve higher ratings than O'Shea.

As for Scholes... his top attributes are Positioning, Vision, Tactical Awareness, Long Passing and Composure, all 93/94. You can't really dispute any of those, therefore you can't really lower his overall rating.

I'll stick with the ratings I posted before.

87 - Wayne ROONEY
87 - Nemanja VIDIC
86 - Dimitar BERBATOV
86 - Edwin VAN DER SAR
86 - Rio FERDINAND
85 - Patrice EVRA
84 - Ryan GIGGS
83 - Paul SCHOLES
83 - Michael CARRICK
82 - Darren FLETCHER
82 - Owen HARGREAVES
82 - ANDERSON
82 - NANI
82 - Antonio VALENCIA
80 - Michael OWEN
79 - Wes BROWN
79 - Jonny EVANS
79 - John O'SHEA
78 - Ji Sung PARK
78 - Gary NEVILLE
78 - Ben FOSTER
76 - Tomasz KUSZCZAK
76 - RAFAEL
76 - FABIO

[kop2k8]

glen johnson has been our best defender this season and is by far better than o'shea.

[kop2k8]

Originally Posted by Super-manc

As for Scholes... his top attributes are Positioning, Vision, Tactical Awareness, Long Passing and Composure, all 93/94. You can't really dispute any of those, therefore you can't really lower his overall rating.

err yes you can considering over the last few years up until they retired both figo and nedved had severe drops in their attributes, especially their key attributes which actually hadnt faded at all.

[kop2k8]

oh and bias ratings.