player ratings - Page 2

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 12:21 AM

Not that overall ratings particularly mean anything, and not that I've not done this before, but I'm bored so what the heck.

89 - Ronaldo
89 - Messi
89 - Casillas
88 - Torres
88 - Buffon
88 - Ibrahimovic
88 - Rooney
88 - Julio Cesar
88 - Gerrard
88 - Vidic
87 - Kaka
87 - Xavi
87 - Villa
87 - Puyol
87 - Ribery
87 - Ferdinand
86 - Fabregas
86 - Cech
86 - Lampard
86 - Iniesta
86 - Eto'o
86 - Arshavin
86 - Terry
86 - Essien
86 - Henry
86 - Lucio

Probably forgotten a few players...

hellchild5 · 21-07-2009, 12:26 AM

AC Milan line up:

GK - Abbiati - 84

LB - Jankulovski - 80
CB - Nesta - 86
CB - Silva - 81
RB - Zambrotta - 84

LCM - Gattuso - 86
CM - Pirlo - 87
RCM - Flamini - 83

LW - Ronaldinho - 86
ST - Pato - 84
RW - Seedorf - 84

I dont know if we will end up getting Fabiano ( 86 ), but if we do id put him and Pato up top with ronaldinho sitting behind them, and put Seedorf on the bench.

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 12:39 AM

I'll do United's ones now.

GK - Van Der Sar - 84

RB - Brown - 80
CB - Ferdinand - 87
CB - Vidic - 88
LB - Evra - 83

RM - Park - 79
CM - Carrick - 83
CM - Anderson - 81
LM - Nani - 81

RS - Berbatov - 86
LS - Rooney - 88

SUB1 - Foster - 77
SUB2 - Evans - 78
SUB3 - O'Shea - 78
SUB4 - Fletcher - 80
SUB5 - Scholes - 82
SUB6 - Giggs - 83
SUB7 - Owen - 80

RES - Macheda - 74
RES - Rafael - 76
RES - Neville - 76
RES - Valencia - 79
RES - Tosic - 73
RES - Hargreaves - 82
RES - Welbeck - 74
RES - Fabio - 74
RES - Kuszczak - 73
RES - Gibson - 73

ashikj · 21-07-2009, 01:21 AM

united line up

vds-85
brown-80
rio-87
vida-89
evra-85
valencia-81
carrick-85
scholes-83
nani-82
berba-85
rooney-88

foster-76
kuszsack-74
rafael-77
neville-76
o'shea-79
evans-78
fabio-74
hargreaves-82
fletcher-80
gibson-74
anderson-82
giggs-83
obertan-72
tosic-74
park-80
macheda-74
wellbeck-72
owen-81

roloman3 · 21-07-2009, 03:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaschPotato

Valencia is average 82 is more than good enough for him. He certainly shouldnt be at Utd

Well he is there, nothing you can do about it now.

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 03:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ant0n

I am pretty lalalalaed off Valencia is a 79.

Why? It's perfect. Good rating.

roloman3 · 21-07-2009, 03:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Why? It's perfect. Good rating.

Seriously, at least an 80, we Ecuadorians have never had a player at 80 or higher in this game, it is about time.

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 03:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by roloman3

Seriously, at least an 80, we Ecuadorians have never had a player at 80 or higher in this game, it is about time.

79 is a strong rating. He is very accurately represented in the game IMO.

jamiemanu1234 · 21-07-2009, 03:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaschPotato

An idiot near the top i see^^EDIT: his name is FallingNine

Whats Gerrard done? Apart form being our best player last season and being one of the best players in the world. He;s 88 usually and thats pretty fair though e should be one more. Cant believe these Mancs at all

Reina 85
Johnson 83
Carragher 86
Skrtel 83
Aurelio 81
Mascherano 85
Alonso 85
Gerrard 88
Kuyt 83
Riera 81
Torres 89 though considering Rooney is usually about 90 Torres should be above him anyway

Thast what i reckon some of ours should be

ha ha ha u make me laugh torres 89 ithin k he should be 87 bcuz didn't he get injured and since then he played boring

Sizzurp · 21-07-2009, 04:11 AM

Why is everyone rating Kaka so low?

2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Top Player
2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Golden Ball
2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Best XI
Time 100 Most Influential People In The World 2009

Maybe he didn't have the best of years, but IMO he's still up there with Ronaldo & Messi.

DerSchatz · 21-07-2009, 09:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sizzurp

Why is everyone rating Kaka so low?

2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Top Player
2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Golden Ball
2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Best XI
Time 100 Most Influential People In The World 2009

Maybe he didn't have the best of years, but IMO he's still up there with Ronaldo & Messi.

no way, kaka had his best in 2007, after that he became a GHOST, in confederation cups he wasnt the best player, it's just he was the best player of the first team, that's all...if not him, then who? elano? melo? i would really have given the golden ball to Fabiano..

Adtiano · 21-07-2009, 09:40 AM

Arsenal
Almunia - 79
Fabianski - 79
Mannone - 73

Sagna - 82
Toure - 83
Gallas - 83
Clichy - 84
Vermealen - 82
Silvestre - 78
Gibbs - 79
Senderos - 80
Djourou - 79
Song - 80

Arshavin - 86
Fabregas - 88
Denilson - 83
Nasri - 85
Eboue - 79
Walcott - 80
Rosicky - 81
Ramsey - 79
Diaby - 80
Wilshere - 78

Eduardo - 83
Van Persie - 86
Bendtner - 77
Vela - 77

Wow, looking at that list we could do with a striker and a midfielder if Wenger's still insistent on not playing Vela. Bendtner is the biggest load of lalalala ever.

Top Players

Casillas - 89
Buffon - 88
Reina - 86
Van Der Sar - 85 (age is all)

Ferdinand - 87
Terry - 87
Vidic - 87
Puyol - 88
Pepe - 84
Albiol - 84

Ronaldo - 89
Messi - 90
Kaka - 89
Benzema - 86
Rooney - 86
Torres - 89
Gerrard - 87
Lampard - 87
Drogba - 85
Eto'o - 88
Ibrahimovic - 87 (purely because he can only play in Serie A)

mikahel · 21-07-2009, 09:43 AM

Messi-91
Ronaldo-90
Eto'o-87/88
Henry-86/87
Imbrahimovic-85/86 (soo overated)
Torres- 87/88
Gerrard-88
Drogba-87
Rooney-87
Kaka-88
Arshavin-87
Van Persie-86
Eduardo-84

MaschPotato · 21-07-2009, 11:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamiemanu1234

ha ha ha u make me laugh torres 89 ithin k he should be 87 bcuz didn't he get injured and since then he played boring

Manu fan

Torres>Rooney

If Rooney is rated 89 then Torres should be 90 FACT.

I would think even a Manc would see that.

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 11:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaschPotato

Manu fan

Torres>Rooney

If Rooney is rated 89 then Torres should be 90 FACT.

I would think even a Manc would see that.

Since when was Rooney rated 89? He'll be 87... again.

MaschPotato · 21-07-2009, 11:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Super-manc

Since when was Rooney rated 89? He'll be 87... again.

It's only an example

He used to be 90 on ps2

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MaschPotato

It's only an example

He used to be 90 on ps2

He was 92 on FIFA 07 PS2

But yeah. It's hard because I think Rooney deserves an 88 but Torres is undoubtedly the better striker. I've given Ronaldo and Messi 89 and Torres isn't as good as them. Meh, I'll just put Ronaldo and Messi on 90 and give Torres 89.

DerSchatz · 21-07-2009, 11:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adtiano

Arsenal
Almunia - 79
Fabianski - 79
Mannone - 73

Sagna - 82
Toure - 83
Gallas - 83
Clichy - 84
Vermealen - 82
Silvestre - 78
Gibbs - 79
Senderos - 80
Djourou - 79
Song - 80

Arshavin - 86
Fabregas - 88
Denilson - 83
Nasri - 85
Eboue - 79
Walcott - 80
Rosicky - 81
Ramsey - 79
Diaby - 80
Wilshere - 78

Eduardo - 83
Van Persie - 86
Bendtner - 77
Vela - 77

Wow, looking at that list we could do with a striker and a midfielder if Wenger's still insistent on not playing Vela. Bendtner is the biggest load of lalalala ever.

Top Players

Casillas - 89
Buffon - 88
Reina - 86
Van Der Sar - 85 (age is all)

Ferdinand - 87
Terry - 87
Vidic - 87
Puyol - 88
Pepe - 84
Albiol - 84

Ronaldo - 89
Messi - 90
Kaka - 89
Benzema - 86
Rooney - 86
Torres - 89
Gerrard - 87
Lampard - 87
Drogba - 85
Eto'o - 88
Ibrahimovic - 87 (purely because he can only play in Serie A)

so will he be like 78 this year?

EAUK_Adroit · 21-07-2009, 11:19 AM

Moved to Database Discussion.

Super-manc · 21-07-2009, 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EAUK_Adroit

Moved to Database Discussion.

That's getting bloody annoying. Can't we have 1 player ratings thread in the FIFA 10 section? Honestly the database discussion might as well be scrapped, hardly anyone comes here.

Adtiano · 21-07-2009, 12:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DerSchatz

so will he be like 78 this year?

Depends, Forlan can play in La Liga

Epic_Red · 21-07-2009, 01:29 PM

Liverpool squad.

reina=87
cavalieri=78

Johnson=83
degen=74
arbeloa=79
Darby=66

Carra=84
Skrtel=84
agger=85
kelly=70
San jose=68

Aurelio=80
Insua=78
dossena=76
buchtmann=66
Mavinga=68

Alonso=86
Mascherano=86
Spearing=74
Plessis=71
Lucas=79

Kuyt=83
El zhar=75
Hammill=76
Amoo=65

Riera=83
Gerardo bruna=67
kackaniglic(spelling) =59

Gerrard=89
Benayoun=82
Dani pacheco=75

Torres=88
babel=79
voronin=79
ngog=77
nemeth=70
saric=69
lauri delle valle=66

Squad=38

Top rated players
messi=91
ronaldo=90
kaka=88
ibra=88
villa=88
ribery=88
eto'o=87
alves=87
henry=86
benzema=86
Rooney=86
ronaldinho=85
and so on...

Roonaldos · 21-07-2009, 10:45 PM

man u
vds 83
rafael 78 ferdinand 87 vidic 89 evra 85
valencia 84 carrick 83 hargreaves 83 nani 79
berbatov 85 rooney 89

foster 79 kuszczak 75
brown 78 neville 75 oshea 76 evans 80 dodo 70 fabio 75
park 79 obertan 73 anderson 79 scholes 77 giggs 79 fletcher 77 gibson 74 possebon(on loan)76 ljajic 70 tosic 70
owen 82 macheda 74 welbeck 73 diouf 73

Roonaldos · 21-07-2009, 10:51 PM

barca
valdes 83
alves 85 puyol 86 marquez 83 abidal 84
xavi 88 toure 84 iniesta 89
messi 91 etoo 86 henry 86

pinto 75 jorquera 70
sylvinho 76 maxwell 81 pique 79 cacares 76 milito 83
keita 80 busquets 79
bojan 81 gudjohnsen 74

Roonaldos · 21-07-2009, 10:59 PM

ronaldo 91
messi 91
casillas 91
torres 90
cesar 90
rooney 89
iniesta 89
kaka 89
vidic 89
gerrard 88
essien
xavi 88
ribery 88
terry 88
villa 87
ibrahimovic 87
lampard 87
ferdinand 87
fabregas 87
diego 87
lucio 87
cech 87
buffon 87
drogba 86
benzema 86
pirlo 86
puyol 86
fabiano 86
etoo 86
henry 86
mascherano
aguero 85
pato 85
berbatov 85
evra 85
lahm 85
ramos 85
maicon 85
de rossi 85
alves 85
reina 85

21-07-2009, 12:21 AM	#26 (permalink)
Super-manc EA Veteran Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Manc-tropolis Posts: 11,477	Not that overall ratings particularly mean anything, and not that I've not done this before, but I'm bored so what the heck. 89 - Ronaldo 89 - Messi 89 - Casillas 88 - Torres 88 - Buffon 88 - Ibrahimovic 88 - Rooney 88 - Julio Cesar 88 - Gerrard 88 - Vidic 87 - Kaka 87 - Xavi 87 - Villa 87 - Puyol 87 - Ribery 87 - Ferdinand 86 - Fabregas 86 - Cech 86 - Lampard 86 - Iniesta 86 - Eto'o 86 - Arshavin 86 - Terry 86 - Essien 86 - Henry 86 - Lucio Probably forgotten a few players... __________________

21-07-2009, 12:26 AM	#27 (permalink)
hellchild5 Forum Regular Join Date: Jul 2008 Posts: 617	AC Milan line up: GK - Abbiati - 84 LB - Jankulovski - 80 CB - Nesta - 86 CB - Silva - 81 RB - Zambrotta - 84 LCM - Gattuso - 86 CM - Pirlo - 87 RCM - Flamini - 83 LW - Ronaldinho - 86 ST - Pato - 84 RW - Seedorf - 84 I dont know if we will end up getting Fabiano ( 86 ), but if we do id put him and Pato up top with ronaldinho sitting behind them, and put Seedorf on the bench. __________________

21-07-2009, 12:39 AM	#28 (permalink)
Super-manc EA Veteran Join Date: Feb 2009 Location: Manc-tropolis Posts: 11,477	I'll do United's ones now. GK - Van Der Sar - 84 RB - Brown - 80 CB - Ferdinand - 87 CB - Vidic - 88 LB - Evra - 83 RM - Park - 79 CM - Carrick - 83 CM - Anderson - 81 LM - Nani - 81 RS - Berbatov - 86 LS - Rooney - 88 SUB1 - Foster - 77 SUB2 - Evans - 78 SUB3 - O'Shea - 78 SUB4 - Fletcher - 80 SUB5 - Scholes - 82 SUB6 - Giggs - 83 SUB7 - Owen - 80 RES - Macheda - 74 RES - Rafael - 76 RES - Neville - 76 RES - Valencia - 79 RES - Tosic - 73 RES - Hargreaves - 82 RES - Welbeck - 74 RES - Fabio - 74 RES - Kuszczak - 73 RES - Gibson - 73 __________________

21-07-2009, 01:21 AM	#29 (permalink)
ashikj Rookie Join Date: Sep 2007 Location: Tanzania Posts: 137	united line up vds-85 brown-80 rio-87 vida-89 evra-85 valencia-81 carrick-85 scholes-83 nani-82 berba-85 rooney-88 foster-76 kuszsack-74 rafael-77 neville-76 o'shea-79 evans-78 fabio-74 hargreaves-82 fletcher-80 gibson-74 anderson-82 giggs-83 obertan-72 tosic-74 park-80 macheda-74 wellbeck-72 owen-81 __________________ United all the way!!!

21-07-2009, 09:40 AM	#37 (permalink)
Adtiano Forum Regular Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 915	Arsenal Almunia - 79 Fabianski - 79 Mannone - 73 Sagna - 82 Toure - 83 Gallas - 83 Clichy - 84 Vermealen - 82 Silvestre - 78 Gibbs - 79 Senderos - 80 Djourou - 79 Song - 80 Arshavin - 86 Fabregas - 88 Denilson - 83 Nasri - 85 Eboue - 79 Walcott - 80 Rosicky - 81 Ramsey - 79 Diaby - 80 Wilshere - 78 Eduardo - 83 Van Persie - 86 Bendtner - 77 Vela - 77 Wow, looking at that list we could do with a striker and a midfielder if Wenger's still insistent on not playing Vela. Bendtner is the biggest load of lalalala ever. Top Players Casillas - 89 Buffon - 88 Reina - 86 Van Der Sar - 85 (age is all) Ferdinand - 87 Terry - 87 Vidic - 87 Puyol - 88 Pepe - 84 Albiol - 84 Ronaldo - 89 Messi - 90 Kaka - 89 Benzema - 86 Rooney - 86 Torres - 89 Gerrard - 87 Lampard - 87 Drogba - 85 Eto'o - 88 Ibrahimovic - 87 (purely because he can only play in Serie A) __________________ suburban idiosyncrasy. i use assisted controls online and offline and you cannot and will not force me to do otherwise.

21-07-2009, 04:11 AM	#35 (permalink)
Sizzurp Rookie Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 255	Why is everyone rating Kaka so low? 2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Top Player 2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Golden Ball 2009 FIFA Confederations Cup Best XI Time 100 Most Influential People In The World 2009 Maybe he didn't have the best of years, but IMO he's still up there with Ronaldo & Messi.

21-07-2009, 09:43 AM	#38 (permalink)
mikahel Forum Regular Join Date: Aug 2008 Posts: 943	Messi-91 Ronaldo-90 Eto'o-87/88 Henry-86/87 Imbrahimovic-85/86 (soo overated) Torres- 87/88 Gerrard-88 Drogba-87 Rooney-87 Kaka-88 Arshavin-87 Van Persie-86 Eduardo-84

21-07-2009, 11:19 AM	#44 (permalink)
EAUK_Adroit Forum Admin Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: UK Age: 22 Posts: 26,908	Moved to Database Discussion. __________________ Adroit Community Representative Electronic Arts Currently playing: Battlefield Bad Company 2 and Ultimate Team 10 Looking forward to: 2010 FIFA World Cup South Africa™ PSN: EAUK_Adroit \|\| Gamertag: EAUK Adroit

21-07-2009, 10:45 PM	#48 (permalink)
Roonaldos Forum Regular Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 628	man u vds 83 rafael 78 ferdinand 87 vidic 89 evra 85 valencia 84 carrick 83 hargreaves 83 nani 79 berbatov 85 rooney 89 foster 79 kuszczak 75 brown 78 neville 75 oshea 76 evans 80 dodo 70 fabio 75 park 79 obertan 73 anderson 79 scholes 77 giggs 79 fletcher 77 gibson 74 possebon(on loan)76 ljajic 70 tosic 70 owen 82 macheda 74 welbeck 73 diouf 73

21-07-2009, 10:51 PM	#49 (permalink)
Roonaldos Forum Regular Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 628	barca valdes 83 alves 85 puyol 86 marquez 83 abidal 84 xavi 88 toure 84 iniesta 89 messi 91 etoo 86 henry 86 pinto 75 jorquera 70 sylvinho 76 maxwell 81 pique 79 cacares 76 milito 83 keita 80 busquets 79 bojan 81 gudjohnsen 74

21-07-2009, 10:59 PM	#50 (permalink)
Roonaldos Forum Regular Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 628	Top Players(in order) ronaldo 91 messi 91 casillas 91 torres 90 cesar 90 rooney 89 iniesta 89 kaka 89 vidic 89 gerrard 88 essien xavi 88 ribery 88 terry 88 villa 87 ibrahimovic 87 lampard 87 ferdinand 87 fabregas 87 diego 87 lucio 87 cech 87 buffon 87 drogba 86 benzema 86 pirlo 86 puyol 86 fabiano 86 etoo 86 henry 86 mascherano aguero 85 pato 85 berbatov 85 evra 85 lahm 85 ramos 85 maicon 85 de rossi 85 alves 85 reina 85 Last edited by Roonaldos; 21-07-2009 at 11:01 PM.