I could care less about the setting, it could pit the smurfs against the snorks, i don't care. What I do care about is the game play. I want it to be balanced, bug free, competitive and fun.
I don't want the next game to support directx 10.1 and have models with 300 million polygons apiece. Devs spend too much time making the game look pretty and not enough time making it play well. But eye candy is what most people want, i guess
